A Stove Comparison: Alcohol (Caldera Cone) vs Canister (Jet Boil, Pocket Rocket, Giga Power)

We had a chance on our 8 day backpack to do some comparisons between some stoves, namely my Caldera Cone with a 1.9 L Evernew titanium pot, an MSR Pocket Rocket, a Snow Peak Giga Power, and a JetBoil.  The latter 3 stoves are canister stoves, and the Caldera Cone is an alcohol stove.  Each of these stoves were cooking for 2 people.  It should be noted that all of these stoves are reliable and they all work fine for heating water.  Some are better in certain situations, and this review compares them for use on an 8 day trip fall, each of them cooking for 2 people.

The Caldera Cone:  This is an alcohol stove, with a conical windscreen on which the pot sits.  The stove is directly below the pot, and the fuel efficiency and heating is improved by the stove being shielded from the wind, and the hot air and flame of the stove being forced along the pot sides.  Its main strengths are being totally silent when cooking, stability, immunity from wind problems, reliability and suitability for all seasons, for a variety of cooking situations.  For instance, we cooked pizza from scratch, toasted bagels, made biscuits, and dishes of pasta, couscous, and rice.

stove plus windscreen, in a plastic screw together tube: 5.4 oz

Evernew 1.9 L titanium pot (to compare with the Jetboil, the pot has to be included) 9.7 oz

fuel taken plus container weight:  21 oz (including 3 oz extra for cushion)

Total weight, stove, pot and fuel, at start of trip: 36.1 oz

Total weight, stove pot and fuel, at end of trip: 18.1 oz

Note: we had 3 oz of fuel left over.

The Caldera Cone and the 1.9 L Evernew pot was a great combination for this trip, for cooking for 2 hikers.  It was quiet, hassle free, fool proof, did well in wind, and cooked a variety of foods, including baking pizza from scratch, bisquits, frying bagels for breakfast, and it could cook a few fish, although we didn’t use it for that because we I talked my son into bringing a bigger frying pan for cooking fish.  The Caldera has the capability of using wood for fuel, which is a good backup if you run out of fuel.

Compared to the Jetboil, the Caldera was 8 oz heavier at the start of the trip, and 2 oz lighter at the end of the trip, due to the weight of the empty gas canister of the Jetboil.  If a crew took an additional small fuel canister for backup for the JetBoil, the Caldera would be the lighter stove setup.  The Caldera was just a hair lighter than a Pocket Rocket setup if used with the same pot.  The Caldera was definitely slower to boil water, but much more versatile at cooking a variety of foods.  The Jetboil is hard to beat for just boiling water.  The fuel weight shown for the Caldera stove is the fuel to just boil water, so it could be compared straight across with the other stoves.  For a menu that included baking, toasting bagels for breakfast, cooking pasta and rice, we used 27 oz of fuel, with 3 oz left over.

All in all, my preference remains the Caldera stove and windscreen.  The JetBoil is actually lighter for this length of a trip, and boils water faster, but is less flexible for different types of cooking. Like any canister stove, it would work less well in the winter, whereas the Caldera works fine at subzero temperatures.  The canister stoves suffered some problems that would not likely ever be a problem with the Caldera.  We had one canister stove tip over with a full pot of boiling water, an indication of their top heavy nature.  We had one canister stove left with the valve not fully closed, and the canister of fuel drained out.  We had one night when a canister stove was totally inoperable due to wind.  All of these situations are just not a problem for the Caldera.

Jet Boil: this is a stove system with a fuel canister, a stove base, and an insulated pot.  It is relatively quiet, super fuel efficient, does well in the wind, and for this length of trip was the lightest combination.  It produces a point source of heat under a tall and narrow insulated pot (the model used on this trip anyway), so it is optimized for boiling water.  It would not do well making cobbler, cooking fish, using with an Outback over, or doing anything except boiling water.  Like any canister stove, it would not do well in winter conditions.

weight of stove plus pot: 15.2 oz

wt. of fuel taken plus container weight: 13 oz (one 220 g fuel canister)

Total weight, stove, pot and fuel, at start of trip: 28.2

total weight, stove, pot and empty fuel canister at end of trip: 20.2 oz (weight of empty fuel container = 5.6 oz)

The JetBoil is an efficient and light weight stove, and with one fuel canister was the lightest combination for this length of trip, cooking for two people.  It is a specialist tool, and is great at boiling water, not cooking pasta, cobbler, biscuits, or trout.  It is fairly quiet, and as reliable as any canister stove.  If you are just boiling water, this stove can’t be beat for weight and speed.  It is very fuel efficient, which allows it to use the fewest fuel canisters for this length of trip.

Pocket Rocket: this is a canister stove with a tiny and light stove that fits on a standard fuel canister.  We had two Pocket Rockets setups, one using 1 large fuel canister and one small canister of fuel, and one with a single canister of fuel.  A single canister of fuel proved to be insufficient, and one large and one small canister was probably the perfect amount of fuel.  Unfortunately, one of the Pocket Rocket teams had a valve that wasn’t fully shut off, and lost a large canister of fuel.  The other Pocket Rocket crew found that one canister of fuel was insufficient, so there was a shortage of fuel toward the end of the trip.  With 4 teams using canister stoves, the canisters could be shifted around to cover the shortages nicely.  A Pocket Rocket tipped over with boiling water.  One has to be careful with these stoves.  There is a 3 legged base for the large canisters that makes any canister stove more stable.  One of the PRs was unable to operate one night due to wind, but that was mainly an experience problem, because a windbreak can usually be found.  The Pocket Rocket is fast to light, and fast to boil water, and not too loud.

The weight for the PR is based on one large and one small canister of fuel, which would probably be ideal for an 8 day trip.  The Evernew 1.9 L pot is used for the weight calculation, to make the weight comparison with the Caldera closer.  The Pocket Rocket setup was right in the ball park with the Caldera as far as weight goes.  With the same pot as the Caldera, the PR was 3 oz lighter at the start of the trip, and 4 oz heavier at the end.  The weights were too close to haggle about.

Wt of stove plus plastic case: 3.9 oz

Evernew 1.9 L titanium pot:  9.7 oz (to compare with the Jetboil, a pot has to be included.  The Evernew was used to make a straight across comparison with the Caldera setup.  Gary’s pot was smaller and only weighed 4 oz)

fuel taken plus container weight:  one large and one small canister: 19.5 oz full, 8.6 oz for empty canisters

Total weight, stove, pot and fuel, at start of trip:  33.1 oz

Total weight, stove pot and fuel, at end of trip: 22.2 oz

 

 

The REI Flash 65 Backpack- a product review

I got an REI Flash 65 because I wanted to lighten my load, and I could save about 3 pounds over my previous pack by using the Flash 65.  My friend Kevin Anderson had said he bought one, and really liked it.  So I bought one for an 8 day backpack we did with the Boy Scouts of Troop 100 in 2009.  Kevin’s Flash 65 was new that year, and mine was brand new on that trip. 

This is Kevin at Edna Lake in the Sawtooths, with his new Flash 65.  The Flash 65 was given the Backpacker Magazine 2009 Editor’s Choice award, and was noted in the April 2011 issue as one of “the best values ever”.  I have to agree.

Mine weighs 3 lb 2 oz, which is more than 3 pounds lighter than my previous pack.  At 65 liters it easily handles gear and food for an 8 day backpack, and is super roomy for a weekend trip.  It has a big pocket on the top flap, a big scoop pocket on the back which can hold a snow shovel or lunch food, elastic mesh side pockets for things like water bottle, tent poles, fishing poles, stove fuel, bear spray, or other things too long to go in the pack, that you don’t want in the pack, or things that need to be readily accessible.

The shoulder straps and waist belt are comfortable, and substantial but not overpadded.  There is a small pocket on one of the waist belt straps for small items like sunblock, chap stick, sunglasses, etc.  The accessible pockets are handy, because the main compartment has no dividers and has access only from the top.  If this is required to keep the weight down, that is fine and I got used to not getting into the main compartment very often during the day.

There are lashing points all over the pack, so like Gary Fujino above, you can attach something to the bottom of the pack, or attach camp shoes to the back of the pack, or strap down a rain coat or jacket.


The one thing that keeps this from being the perfect pack is that the top flap does not turn into a day pack.  This defect can be easily remedied by bringing a strap or two to allow the top flap to be carried over the shoulder or with a strap around the waist .  The pack comes in S, M and L, and I would highly recommend this pack for up to 8 day trips.

Handy Survival Bracelet

A friend of mine and adviser to our scout troop makes and sells some really cool survival bracelets, which look great and also are a great survival and woodcraft tool.  Since they are made of 7 feet of paracord, which can hold 550 lbs of weight, they can be taken apart for use as cord if the need arises.  If taken apart, they can be rewoven for free.  Thus you always have a reserve of paracord for emergencies, like replacing a shoelace, a tent guy line, making a bow drill to make fire, making a shelter, making a tourniquet, and many other necessities.  They can be seen at Custom Paracord Creations.

The one below is a dog collar sturdy enough to hold any dog!

Kane Lake in the Pioneer Range of Idaho

Over Labor Day we repeated our annual trek to the nicest lake I know of in Idaho – Kane Lake.  Its only 3.5 miles, but its uphill, rocky and an unmaintained trail.  The views from camp at Kane lake are unsurpassed in Idaho.

This is the view looking back down the valley as one nears the lake.  The trail is unmaintained, and uphill, but at 3.5 miles its not very far to hike in.

This is the first view you see of the lake.  There is a waterfall that comes down the cliff on the opposite side of the lake, and another waterfall where the inlet to the lake cascades down from the basin above.

Jim and Kenna tuck into some pudding packs.  Those looked pretty good!

Bob and Tuckie relaxing around the fire in the evening.

Here is the crew on this trip: me, Dave Litster, Dallon Litster, Jun Campion, Kenna Nowak, Jim Shaver and Tuckie Shaver and Ginger the Wonderdog.

 

Some Berries seen on our Fall hike to Kane Lake

These are all conspicuous berries we saw on our fall hike in the Pioneer Range.  Some are edible, some not so edible.

These are gooseberries, which are the same genus (Ribes) as currants.  If the plants have spines they are gooseberries, if not they are currants.  These are tart berries, getting a little sweeter as they get very ripe.  They are wonderful to munch on, and the spines look a lot worse than they are.

This is Twinberry, Lanicera involurata, which is related to honeysuckle.  The berries are edible but taste bitter.

This is another gooseberry, also called Bristly Black Currant.  These are very good.

The fourth conspicuous berry we saw on this trip was soapberry, Sheperdia canadensis.  These berries have a bitter taste, but get better as they get ripe and after a few frosts.  They can be used to make pemmican. When whipped with a whisk they form a foam called Indian Ice Cream, which is much improved by adding sugar.

Above, Rubus idaeus, raspberry, edible and tasty

Elderberry,genus Sambucus, and  the seeds contain hydrocyanic acid, and cause diarrhea and nausea if eaten in quantity.

I think this is Baneberry, Actaea rubra, and the berries are poisonous.

White Cloud Mountains, Idaho, Castle Peak Loop

We finished a great 8 day backpack in the White Clouds, and were surprised to find lakes there that are better than any in the Sawtooths, and in general had a great time.

Below is the gang, 5 adults and 6 youths.

We started at 4th of July Lake, with camp sites at

Washtington Lake

Chamberlain Basin

Hatchet Lake in the Boulder Chain Lakes

Hummock Lake in the upper Boulder Chain Lakes

and from there we hiked out via Quiet Lake and 4 Lakes Basin to Born Lakes

Our group had some fantastic mountain experience, and our campfires had some interesting and entertaining stories.  Josh, 2nd from left, is a Marine who was in Saudi, Jordan, and other places in the Middle East, as a trainer to their marines, and has lots of great stories from Marine days.

Gary, far right, did a lot of rock climbing in So Cal and Yosemite.  He climbed the Nose route on El Cap in Yosemite, hiked the John Muir Trail, and has lots of rock and peak climbing and backpacking experience.

Kevin, 2nd from right, did the John Muir Trail in a 27 day trip at when he was 15, did many 9 day hikes in the Sierra, and joined me on our Sawtooth Slowpoke and Wind River hikes.

Dave, who joined us after this picture was taken, has climbed a lot of Colorado 14ers and has done a lot of backpacks in the West.

My lovely wife Tuckie (in the photo above) hiked in with us to Washington Lake, then headed out and spent some time with friends in Ketchum.

This is a view of Castle Peak as we head into Chamberlain Basin for our 2nd night’s camp.

Above is a view of Castle Peak from our camp at the first big lake in Chamberlain Basin.  I had to admit I could not think of a better camp site, or a better view from a campsite.  Kane Lake in the Pioneers, Sawtooth Lake in the Sawtooths, Alice Lake in the Sawtooths, Titcombe Basin in the Winds are all good, but this view and campsite were right up there.

Four of our party climbed this side of Castle: Gary, Dave, Malcolm, and Nick.  Another group of our youths went around the lakes dispersing illegal fire pits, as part of Jim’s Eagle Project.  Kevin caught a lot of fish at the upper Chamberlain basin, mostly due to persistence on a windy day.  He and Josh “saw” a 26″ fish.  Yeah, right.

Above is a view of the East side of Castle Peak, as we headed to Big Boulder Chain Lakes. We camped at Hatchet Lake, and the next day headed up to the upper lakes of the chain.  Hummock Lake was another standout lake, and all the lakes had good fishing, but the fish were generally small.

Above is a view of Hummock Lake, where we had a layover day.  Even prettier lakes were those at higher elevations, and the next one, Scoop Lake, had a good campsite at the inlet.

Shown above is Lonesome Lake, the highest lake in the Boulder Chain Lakes, at 10,435.  It didn’t have ice on the water, but the slopes above the lake were all snow covered, in late August.  Its been a late season this year.

Above are Dave, Tomio, Gary, and Kade, on a day hike to Lonesome lake, and Hidden lake for fishing.

Above is a typical grouping around a campfire, this one at Hummock Lake.

Here are the boys as we rested at Scree Lake, before heading to Quiet Lake and the Four Lakes Basin.

Above, Quiet Lake.

Above, some of the lakes of the 4 Lakes Basin, from the pass above them.

We took a tough route to get down to Born Lakes, but Kevin and Josh had gone via the shorter Devils Staircase route, and had saved a campsite for the whole group.  One of the Born Lakes is above.

The mountain scenery was fine, but what really inspired the troops for the last few days of the trip was a vision of the hamburgers at the Bridge Grill in Lower Stanley.  It was as good as we imagined it.

The Yutes have Grown Up

In 2007 I took 3 scouts on a great 4 day backpack, the Alice Toxaway Loop in the Sawtooths of Idaho.  Those same 3 yutes were on a trip last weekend.  The purpose of the trip was to help Lars with his Eagle Project.  Malcolm has also done his Eagle Project.  Jim is the last holdout to finish his Eagle Project.  Here are pics of the gang in 2007, and the same people from the past weekend.

Lars, Jim, Malcolm, me and Ginger the dog, 2007 on Alice Toxaway backpack.

Malcolm Jim, Lars, me, and Ginger, July 2011

Canoeing on Owyhee Reservior

There is still 10′ of snow at Sawtooth Lake, so its good timing that we have been doing some canoeing.  We launched our boats at Leslie Gulch, and headed up the lake toward a hot springs.  We turned around before the hot springs, because the wind was picking up and we would be fighting the wind on the return route.

 

Scout Backpack to Wilderness Hot Spring, and Morel Mushrooms

I led a scout backpack on the Middle Fork of the Payette in Idaho, and was reminded how delicious morel mushrooms are.  It has been a wet spring here, and we found maybe 30 morels around our camp, and it added a bit of interest to the freeze dried menu.

We hiked about 2 miles to a nice wilderness hot springs, where we quickly found out it could hold all 12 of the scouts on our trip.

After that, the first order of business at our camp was for Tom B. to get across the stream with dry feet.  So do you think he made it?

No, he didn’t!  his right foot dragged in the water, and he got a wet foot.

Shortly after that the scouts started finding morels around their camp.  The interest quickly spread to the scouters, and both groups fried up some morels for a snack.

Rain was predicted for the weekend, and we got lucky enough to get our tents up before it rained or hailed.  We had hail and rain for about an hour, and light sprinkles till bedtime.

Bob’s Survival Kit

This survival kit is put together so that a hiker will have greatly improved chances of surviving a few days in the mountains.  It is small and light enough so that a hiker need never hesitate to take it along on even a day hike.  I have been on many mountain rescues where a hiker left for a short day hike in warm fall weather, often wearing shorts and a T shirt, then got disoriented and the weather turned bad, and he ended up spending the night out in bad weather wearing shorts and t shirt.  The kit can’t prevent stupidity, but if you always throw this in your day pack or fanny pack, you will have greatly improved chances of surviving one or two nights in the mountains.  But it’s like wearing seatbelts or any other kind of insurance, you have to always use it so that on that rare occaision when you need it, it will be there to save your butt.

Contents of the survival kit:

Stainless steel salt shaker with lid

Foil emergency blanket

rain hat

butane lighter

knife and firestarting steel

duct tape

candle

signal mirror

whistle

nylon cord

compass/thermometer

brass wire

fishing equipment

can opener

pins, needles, and safety pins

boullion cubes

screw in hooks

safety pins

matches

fire starter material

Life in general requires just three things: food, water, and warmth (not counting air, which I assume is always available).  To survive in the mountains you don’t need food.  You can go for many days without food.  Water is usually available in the mountains, so I won’t discuss it.  So what is left is warmth, and that is the main thing which you need to survive for several days in the mountains.  Hypothermia, the loss of body heat, is what people die of when they are lost.  The object of this kit, and the object of the lost person, is to maintain enough body heat to last for several days in the mountains, until you are found by rescuers.  What this kit is aimed at then are things which help you keep warm and things with which to signal your rescuers.

The signaling supplies include a whistle, a mirror, and fire making tools.  Blowing a whistle takes much less energy than yelling, doesn’t tire you out, and is heard at a much greater distance than yelling.  Three blasts on a whistle every five minutes is enough to start a rescue.  Mountain rescue has often been activated when a hiker tells the sheriff that he heard three blasts on a whistle every five minutes coming from somewhere on the side of a mountain.

The mirror is for signaling in daylight.  Reflected sunlight carries amazingly well, and is especially useful for signalling airplanes or helicopters.  To aim it, align some sighting device such as a long stick or your finger, with the thing you are aiming at.  Then move the spot of reflected light to hit the stick or your finger held up in a line with the target.  When the spot of light hits your finger or the twig, it is also hitting the target.

Making a fire is good both as a signaling device and a way to keep warm.  At night have a bright fire, during the day have a fire with good coals that you occasionally throw leaves on to make it smokey.  Airplanes will be circling the area where you are lost, and will see the smoke from a great distance.  When the woods are wet or when it is raining you can usually find dry twigs on the trunk of trees, under the rain protection of the upper branches.  The candle is to start a fire using semi wet twigs.  Build a loose criss-crossed stack or a teepee of twigs around the candle, light the candle and move twigs into its flame until they start.  Add bigger and bigger twigs, until you can burn big branches and even logs.  Leave the candle under the twigs to keep them going and dry them out.  You should practice making a fire using natural tinder materials, and when the woods are wet from dew or rain.  There are fire starting materials in the kit, but not a lot, so you should be able to start a fire using only one match, using natural tinder (not paper) and in damp conditions.

There is a square of fire making material which will light and burn when its wet.  It is pressed together wood chips and plastic beads.

The emergency blanket can be used for signaling, but is mainly for warmth.  Staying warm in the mountains means staying dry, since your body heat is expended to dry out the water in your hair, clothes and skin if they are wet.  When water evaporates it absorbs a lot of energy, and results in a cooling of the surface from which it evaporates.  This is called evaporative cooling.   If you are the surface from which water evaporates, you will become very chilled as it evaporates.  If you are wet and in a wind, evaporative cooling takes your body heat even quicker as the water evaporates faster.  If you can keep dry means you will retain a lot of body heat that you will lose if you are wet.  However, if you become wet, you can stay warm as long as the water doesn’t evaporate. The way to do this is to wrap your wet parts in plastic, so even though they are wet, they are not evaporating.  This method can be used by putting plastic bags over your wet socks, or putting a plastic garbage bag on as a poncho, over your sweater, but under your coat. I once hiked into a mountain lake wearing running shoes one Fall weekend, and we awoke to six inches of snow on the ground and had 12 miles to hike out.  I put plastic bags over my wool socks, and hiked out with wet, but warm, feet.

Keeping warm also means keeping out of the wind.  The wind takes your heat away both by evaporative cooling and also by conducting heat away from your skin and clothes.  The foil blanket is included to keep you warm, dry, and out of the wind. It is waterproof, windproof, and reflects body heat.  Be careful not to tear it when you sit down or lay on it.

The part of the body which radiates heat away the fastest is the head.  If you are cold, covering your head with a wool cap, a baseball cap, or anything will reduce the radiation from your head, and your whole body will get warmer.  That is where the old saying comes from that if you have cold feet, put on a hat.  If your head is wet and you are in cold weather, your head loses heat both by radiation from its surface, which is richly supplied with blood, but also by evaporative cooling, in which your body heat is used in the evaporation of water.  To prevent this heat loss from your head, wear a wool hat.  Included in the kit is a plastic rain hat, which will keep your head dry, and keep the wind from removing the layer of warm air that forms near your skin. If you don’t have a wool cap, this is better than nothing, and could be a lifesaver.

The compass can help if you know how to use it.  It is not meant to replace your main compass on a backpack, but is there just in case.  Its a good idea to check your compass when you leave for your hike, and to know your route on the map, so you know which general direction you will be coming and going.  If you have done this, and then get lost in thick woods or fog, the compass will save your bacon and keep you going in the right direction.  If you don’t know which way is the right direction, the compass isn’t much good to you.  When using a compass, be sure to hold it some distance away from metal objects, such as the steel cup of the survival kit, or the metal will attract the needle of the compass and give you a wrong direction.

The cup which holds the survival gear can be used to scoop a shelter in the snow, which is about the only way to stay alive overnight in the winter.  It can also be heated over a fire to warm water, which will warm a cold person by directly putting heat into their body in the warm liquid.  Melting snow or ice over a fire is much better than melting snow in your mouth, since the latter drains your body of the heat used to melt the ice or snow.  For that reason, always use liquid water in the winter rather than melt it in your mouth, in order to conserve body heat.  The cup can also be available as a spare cup on a backpack, where a forgotten cup can be a disaster.  The hook handle of the cup can be hooked under a belt if you go hiking without even a daypack or fanny pack, which would be an idiotic thing to do.

The nylon cord can serve many purposes.  It is braided fishing line, with about a 180 lb test.  That makes it strong enough to hang a bear bag, or to string a tube tent or replace a shoelace or tent line.  It can be used to fix gear, tie up the blanket as a tarp, or to make a bow for starting a fire using sticks.  It can be a spare shoe lace, a fish stringer, tourniquet material, used with branches to make a splint for broken bones. It can be an emergency sleeping bag strap, food hanger, clothesline, or tent line.

The bouillon cubes are there because even though you can survive for quite a while without food, your body needs salt if it has been sweating a lot.  If you lack salt, you get muscle cramps, weakness, and painful spasms.  A couple of bouillon cubes each day prevents these symptoms and can keep you functioning. You can just chew them up and swallow them, or use the metal cup to heat up water and make a warming broth.  I had a guy swallow one without chewing it, and it just about killed him.  Chew it first.

Some of the other equipment is in the kit not because it is needed for survival, but because it isn’t heavy or big, and can save the day on a backpack, hike, or climb.  The can opener, safety pins and needles and thread are in that category.  One one winter trip, a guy had a busted zipper on his sleeping bag.  We connected it up with safety pins, and improved his comfort a good deal.  As I mentioned, food is not a survival need, but the fishing gear is included for fun and because it doesn’t weigh much.  One fly is an Adams, which looks like a mayfly to trout.  It is a dry fly and will float down a stream with the current.  The line included is about 20 feet of very fine fly fishing leader.  This leader is about as thick as spider web, and not very strong.  However, it floats on water and will help make the Adams look like a bug to a feeding trout.  The other fly is a wooly bugger, which will sink and pull the leader under with it.  This looks like a leech or a dislodged insect larvae to the trout, and should be allowed to drift into holes and pockets behind boulders.  The leader is not strong, so you will have to tire a big fish out before dragging him in, or he will break the line.  Tie the line to a willow branch to give it some spring so it won’t break when a big fish hits it.  Try an insect on the hook if the flies don’t work, such as grasshoppers, wasp, worms, or larvae.

The brass wire can be used to suspend the steel cup over a fire, to repair a pack, or other repair tasks.

The screw in hooks can be used to screw into tree trunks to support a line and hold up a shelter.  I taped one onto a tent pole once and retrieved a fishing reel from deep water.

When you realize that you are lost, it is best to just stop right there, or at least well before dark, get comfortable, get a stock of wood, start a fire, and wait.  The forest service tells children to “hug a tree” when you are lost, meaning to adopt a big tree to sit under and wait for help.  The old wive’s tale is that if you always go downhill, you will eventually run across a road or trail.  But that isn’t always the case.  I was on a mountain rescue where a hiker in t-shirt and shorts (the official attire for lost idiot hikers) climbed up to a ridge in the mountains.  As he came down the ridge back toward camp, he got going down a twisting ravine which went down the wrong side of the mountain.  That side of the mountain led into the Yakima Indian reservation, where there were no roads for 80 miles.  He hiked down the mountain and spent the night out in the cold fall air.  The next day we were tracking him from where he was last seen, but he could go much faster than we could since he didn’t have a pack and we had to look for his tracks in sandy areas.  He would have outrun us and been deep into the reservation for another cold night out, except that we sent searchers on horses ahead after him.  On another rescue skiiers who lost their way on a ski tour went downhill when their trail traversed a valley.  The stream they followed led into a steep narrow gully, and they finally reached a point where it was too steep and scary for them to go on.  It would have been much easier to rescue them from higher up the canyon.

Something else that happens on rescues, especially rescues for lost kids, is that they try to avoid the rescuers.  For some reason kids will hide from the rescuers, avoid them, and not answer their calls.  The rescuers will not be mad at you for being lost. They will be greatly relieved that they can bring back a live person instead of a body, so don’t hide from them.  When you are lost, finding any person, even a stranger, is what you should be trying to do.

Always let someone else know you are leaving on a mountain trip, where you are going, and when you plan to get back.  And when you get back, always give them a call to let them know you are back.  Be sure the person who knows where you are going also knows to call the sheriff if you aren’t back in a reasonable time.

A hiker should always carry certain gear, even if out for a short walk in good weather.  They call this list of equipment the “Ten essentials”, which I think has now grown to the 13 essentials.  They are: extra clothing, extra food, sunglasses, knife, firestarter, First Aid kit, matches, flashlight, map and compass.  You should have all of these, and in addition, throw in the survival kit.  Don’t rely on the compass or fire starter tools in the survival kit to meet the 10 essentials, unless you’re just out on a short day hike.  For longer hikes or overnight packpacks, make the kit your backup to the 10 essentials you carry in your pack.

Besides the 10 essentials and the survival kit, a person can greatly improve their chances of surviving in the woods, and also of being comfortable, by wearing the right kind of clothes.  You should always wear synthetic (pile, fleece, polypro, nylon, polyester) or wool.  The least preferred is cotton, such as in jeans, T-shirts, and sweatshirts.  Unfortunately, these are the clothes most often worn by people as casual wear.   A nylon windbreaker, or better yet a goretex lined windbreaker, adds a great margin of safety and comfort to a wardrobe, and can be compactly stored in a fanny pack.  A wool hat is an important item to add, for reasons discussed below.  Wool or wool blend socks are a must, and an inner pair of light polypro socks are nice, and again cotton is to be avoided at all cost.  A fleece or pile pullover is great.  Light polypro or polyester gloves are great to add, and are light and small enough to leave in the pockets of the windbreaker at all times.